Ahlemeyer Bakery
closed today
Dessert shop Bakery Café
We are a small family bakery that has been in Columbus over 30 years! Update description
Reviews
Updates (5)
Review Ahlemeyer Bakery
Loading comments-box...
Dave M. 2015-10-12You get what you pay for. Great pies. Sometimes the favorite one you wanted is sold out. Usually a very good 2nd option in available.
Cathy O'Dell M. 2015-06-18I came from a long line of pie bakers. These pies (and other pastry goodies) are just awesome! I get them for all the holidays and special...
Sandhyaa J. 2018-03-28My husband surprised me with a VEGAN CHOCOLATE CAKE from this amazing place yesterday for my birthday. It was so decadent, spongy and yum! Pls pls try...
Kathy Pedigo W. 2018-01-23Love their pies!! Haven’t been there in a few years but my favorite was Sugar Cream!!
Christy M. 2017-01-01My family orders pies for the holidays every year. They never disappoint!
Lisa R. 2016-10-21I love all the bakery items they sell but my #1 favorite is the peanut butter pie!
Devon K. 2016-09-16It took me a while to find a butterscotch pie as good as my great grandma made for our family reunions....but I found one!
Kelsey J. 2016-07-05We pick up random pies from Hackmans! So far the Kentucky Chocolate Pie has been the BEST!!
Naomi P. 2015-11-25The best baked goods I have ever tasted next to my Grandma's! Wonderful staff and oh...the smells eminating from that place!!! Love it!
Ronald Edward M. 2015-08-31I Believe that this place is the best and I absolutely love the product they put out.
CsaFodrea F. 2015-08-30We use Ahlemeyer's for all of our class events and rewards...excellent service and excellent products!
Stacey Sinkes L. 2015-06-18The closest I can get to my Grandma's Rhubarb Pie! Thank You!
Crystal A. 2014-09-26Excellent Pies... Sugar Cream is to die for!
Doug F. 2014-02-05The blueberry pie is the best I have ever had! Always great food and service!!
Sheila K. 1969-12-31Yum had the butterscotch pie!! It was delicious and crust was so light and crispy!!
Sally S. 1969-12-31Stopped here yesterday on our way back to Fort Wayne. SO glad we did! The Butterscotch Pie, Peanut butter blossom cookies and the Lemon Bars were...
Camille M. 1969-12-31Loved the Apple Crumb pie I ordered for this Thanksgiving!
Tisha T. 1969-12-31The best pie maker EVER. The crust is superb. Creme pies are to die for and the Kentucky Pie makes me cry with tears of joy.
Updates from Ahlemeyer Bakery
Ahlemeyer Farms B. 2017-09-23
What?! Yes! You asked and we’ve answered: healthy baked goods!!! Come try them today!
What?! Yes! You asked and we’ve answered: healthy baked goods!!! Come try them today!
Ahlemeyer Farms B. 2017-07-24
Which sounds more refreshing on a hot summer day? Fresh strawberry pie, or a slice of lemon meringue? Maybe the answer is both!
Which sounds more refreshing on a hot summer day? Fresh strawberry pie, or a slice of lemon meringue? Maybe the answer is both!
Ahlemeyer Farms B. 2017-06-26
Yum! Come on in for some old fashioned goodness!
Yum! Come on in for some old fashioned goodness!
Ahlemeyer Farms B. 2017-06-26
Come try our fresh zucchini bread- now made with local green and yellow zucchini from Hackman's Farmers Market!
Come try our fresh zucchini bread- now made with local green and yellow zucchini from Hackman's Farmers Market!
Ahlemeyer Farms B. 2017-06-24
Sweet Saturday special: our take on the Boston Cream Pie! Only one left today, but if you place an order we can make one any time!
Sweet Saturday special: our take on the Boston Cream Pie! Only one left today, but if you place an order we can make one any time!
Popularity of Ahlemeyer Bakery
Social Media Popularity Score: This value is based on the number of visitors, checkins, and likes on Facebook in the last few months.
Most activity in May:
Ahlemeyer Bakery has a total of 184 visitors (checkins) and 3863 likes.
14 reviews of Ahlemeyer Bakery.
Average grade
5
av 5.
Geri Girl Bakery
Hostess Cakes